Instance m_83_14_1.dat Number of customers: 83 Number of periods: 14 Solution cost: 141739 >> PERIOD 1 > ROUTE 1: Customers: 23 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 34(35) 77(28) 26(2) 42(60) 59(27) 38(12) 71(13) 68(16) 60(52) 73(65) 65(21) 69(50) 3(51) 52(12) 32(8) 46(45) 9(15) 13(24) 55(30) 82(36) 67(52) 79(96) 44(25) 0 >> PERIOD 2 > ROUTE 1: Customers: 22 Vehicle: 2 Sequence: 0 39(36) 76(19) 22(80) 49(40) 58(98) 32(52) 57(45) 46(60) 9(60) 40(65) 13(30) 55(15) 43(33) 53(16) 21(54) 8(12) 7(39) 70(48) 23(8) 67(24) 81(42) 30(105) 0 > ROUTE 2: Customers: 31 Vehicle: 2 Sequence: 0 35(22) 34(63) 74(24) 45(55) 18(30) 37(38) 26(68) 77(70) 25(10) 17(28) 4(39) 11(44) 59(27) 72(26) 64(35) 5(51) 38(36) 62(32) 71(78) 68(32) 60(104) 69(40) 14(60) 65(70) 73(13) 15(32) 36(15) 1(51) 3(85) 52(30) 44(70) 0 >> PERIOD 3 > ROUTE 1: Customers: 9 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 21(86) 46(27) 9(90) 40(39) 13(57) 55(105) 43(88) 53(28) 29(17) 0 > ROUTE 2: Customers: 9 Vehicle: 3 Sequence: 0 82(84) 57(81) 32(16) 8(30) 7(65) 70(48) 23(96) 81(70) 30(30) 0 > ROUTE 3: Customers: 12 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 48(28) 27(72) 60(13) 69(100) 73(13) 15(24) 47(57) 36(30) 80(96) 16(13) 76(57) 39(54) 0 > ROUTE 4: Customers: 9 Vehicle: 4 Sequence: 0 41(88) 5(48) 38(48) 62(16) 65(56) 14(20) 71(39) 64(70) 72(91) 0 > ROUTE 5: Customers: 8 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 45(95) 18(66) 37(95) 42(20) 63(13) 31(84) 11(94) 59(90) 0 > ROUTE 6: Customers: 7 Vehicle: 3 Sequence: 0 66(36) 79(96) 49(40) 22(80) 6(16) 83(75) 44(10) 0 > ROUTE 7: Customers: 10 Vehicle: 4 Sequence: 0 54(70) 24(46) 52(72) 3(34) 1(68) 51(32) 68(56) 19(24) 20(6) 67(88) 0 > ROUTE 8: Customers: 12 Vehicle: 2 Sequence: 0 35(34) 12(21) 26(92) 77(28) 4(52) 17(28) 28(22) 25(60) 56(48) 78(56) 34(63) 74(12) 0 > ROUTE 9: Customers: 11 Vehicle: 2 >> PERIOD 4 > ROUTE 1: Customers: 3 Vehicle: 2 Sequence: 0 6(60) 76(57) 39(72) 0 > ROUTE 2: Customers: 6 Vehicle: 3 Sequence: 0 83(50) 71(65) 62(64) 38(72) 72(52) 50(54) 0 > ROUTE 3: Customers: 8 Vehicle: 3 Sequence: 0 24(16) 51(32) 73(65) 15(48) 47(15) 36(70) 69(30) 60(78) 0 > ROUTE 4: Customers: 4 Vehicle: 5 Sequence: 0 34(63) 74(48) 12(72) 35(66) 0 > ROUTE 5: Customers: 7 Vehicle: 3 Sequence: 0 52(66) 3(85) 80(56) 16(26) 57(36) 32(44) 79(40) 0 > ROUTE 6: Customers: 8 Vehicle: 3 Sequence: 0 29(34) 43(22) 55(15) 13(33) 40(39) 9(60) 46(69) 82(96) 0 > ROUTE 7: Customers: 9 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 49(30) 19(72) 31(42) 77(14) 26(20) 37(57) 18(72) 45(80) 27(36) 0 > ROUTE 8: Customers: 4 Vehicle: 5 Sequence: 0 48(70) 63(91) 59(81) 44(100) 0 > ROUTE 9: Customers: 7 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 33(70) 78(63) 25(35) 28(99) 17(84) 4(13) 61(70) 0 > ROUTE 10: Customers: 7 Vehicle: 4 Sequence: 0 67(32) 23(48) 53(80) 21(80) 58(70) 8(30) 66(18) 0 > ROUTE 11: Customers: 5 Vehicle: 4 Sequence: 0 64(65) 5(75) 41(99) 11(78) 42(36) 0 > ROUTE 12: Customers: 6 Vehicle: 4 Sequence: 0 68(40) 1(85) 2(90) 65(63) 14(40) 75(36) 0 > ROUTE 13: Customers: 6 Vehicle: 4 Sequence: 0 81(56) 70(64) 20(63) 22(30) 10(56) 54(60) 0 > ROUTE 14: Customers: 6 Vehicle: 4 >> PERIOD 5 > ROUTE 1: Customers: 2 Vehicle: 4 Sequence: 0 48(14) 27(45) 0 > ROUTE 2: Customers: 6 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 16(26) 80(48) 36(90) 47(96) 15(56) 73(52) 0 > ROUTE 3: Customers: 7 Vehicle: 4 Sequence: 0 11(34) 31(42) 64(90) 6(60) 22(20) 19(24) 49(60) 0 > ROUTE 4: Customers: 5 Vehicle: 3 Sequence: 0 72(65) 71(39) 65(91) 14(80) 10(56) 0 > ROUTE 5: Customers: 7 Vehicle: 4 Sequence: 0 8(78) 13(21) 9(75) 40(65) 53(24) 23(24) 67(48) 0 > ROUTE 6: Customers: 6 Vehicle: 3 Sequence: 0 74(60) 45(20) 42(64) 63(78) 41(66) 38(72) 0 > ROUTE 7: Customers: 8 Vehicle: 4 Sequence: 0 30(15) 7(104) 58(70) 32(32) 57(27) 46(12) 82(48) 20(12) 0 > ROUTE 8: Customers: 6 Vehicle: 3 Sequence: 0 52(48) 3(51) 69(70) 60(52) 5(72) 83(45) 0 > ROUTE 9: Customers: 10 Vehicle: 2 Sequence: 0 34(28) 78(42) 4(65) 17(35) 28(22) 25(35) 56(72) 77(21) 33(10) 35(28) 0 > ROUTE 10: Customers: 6 Vehicle: 2 Sequence: 0 12(63) 18(42) 37(76) 26(92) 61(50) 59(18) 0 > ROUTE 11: Customers: 3 Vehicle: 5 Sequence: 0 76(76) 39(90) 79(152) 0 > ROUTE 12: Customers: 8 Vehicle: 2 Sequence: 0 75(20) 62(48) 51(16) 1(68) 68(48) 24(50) 54(80) 44(30) 0 > ROUTE 13: Customers: 7 Vehicle: 2 Sequence: 0 81(42) 70(64) 29(68) 43(77) 55(60) 21(34) 66(24) 0 >> PERIOD 6 > ROUTE 1: Customers: 5 Vehicle: 5 Sequence: 0 12(30) 77(91) 61(20) 42(84) 75(100) 0 > ROUTE 2: Customers: 4 Vehicle: 4 Sequence: 0 21(92) 8(72) 26(98) 37(76) 0 > ROUTE 3: Customers: 6 Vehicle: 3 Sequence: 0 76(76) 19(48) 32(44) 57(81) 58(56) 34(49) 0 > ROUTE 4: Customers: 7 Vehicle: 2 Sequence: 0 35(12) 33(28) 25(80) 28(33) 17(70) 4(65) 78(77) 0 > ROUTE 5: Customers: 7 Vehicle: 3 Sequence: 0 74(84) 18(30) 11(16) 31(98) 63(13) 83(50) 30(60) 0 > ROUTE 6: Customers: 7 Vehicle: 3 Sequence: 0 54(60) 24(26) 3(68) 10(98) 22(20) 49(20) 20(39) 0 > ROUTE 7: Customers: 4 Vehicle: 4 Sequence: 0 44(100) 16(78) 29(85) 23(80) 0 > ROUTE 8: Customers: 7 Vehicle: 4 Sequence: 0 51(48) 47(96) 15(32) 73(13) 60(78) 1(17) 52(60) 0 > ROUTE 9: Customers: 5 Vehicle: 4 Sequence: 0 2(90) 65(91) 14(80) 62(16) 71(52) 0 > ROUTE 10: Customers: 3 Vehicle: 2 Sequence: 0 48(84) 45(95) 50(108) 0 > ROUTE 11: Customers: 7 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 6(64) 72(26) 64(95) 38(84) 5(90) 41(77) 59(27) 0 > ROUTE 12: Customers: 9 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 27(18) 67(36) 70(16) 53(52) 80(88) 36(70) 69(40) 68(80) 66(69) 0 > ROUTE 13: Customers: 8 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 82(60) 46(12) 9(45) 40(52) 13(87) 55(90) 43(22) 39(90) 0 > ROUTE 14: Customers: 6 Vehicle: 1 > ROUTE 15: Customers: 6 Vehicle: 1 >> PERIOD 7 > ROUTE 1: Customers: 14 Vehicle: 2 Sequence: 0 12(36) 18(36) 37(95) 61(90) 26(34) 77(7) 4(65) 17(14) 28(22) 25(55) 56(84) 78(63) 33(26) 74(24) 0 > ROUTE 2: Customers: 10 Vehicle: 2 Sequence: 0 79(104) 81(42) 67(32) 23(96) 70(80) 82(36) 20(66) 19(60) 22(20) 39(90) 0 > ROUTE 3: Customers: 3 Vehicle: 2 Sequence: 0 48(35) 27(90) 30(45) 0 > ROUTE 4: Customers: 14 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 29(51) 21(14) 53(20) 43(77) 55(30) 13(9) 9(90) 40(91) 46(87) 57(90) 32(88) 58(42) 8(36) 7(117) 0 > ROUTE 5: Customers: 13 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 72(91) 64(45) 5(30) 41(44) 38(72) 62(96) 14(50) 65(77) 15(80) 47(93) 69(20) 71(65) 83(90) 0 > ROUTE 6: Customers: 12 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 52(90) 16(104) 80(96) 3(85) 36(35) 73(65) 60(52) 51(48) 1(68) 68(96) 54(10) 66(99) 0 > ROUTE 7: Customers: 14 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 49(40) 6(32) 76(95) 24(34) 75(168) 59(18) 11(26) 31(84) 63(26) 42(56) 45(25) 34(91) 35(78) 44(95) 0 >> PERIOD 8 > ROUTE 1: Customers: 11 Vehicle: 3 Sequence: 0 39(18) 76(19) 6(56) 22(80) 19(36) 20(15) 82(48) 70(80) 23(96) 67(92) 30(45) 0 > ROUTE 2: Customers: 18 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 81(28) 29(34) 8(96) 21(76) 53(20) 43(11) 55(75) 13(87) 40(78) 9(30) 46(81) 58(84) 32(92) 57(45) 16(78) 80(48) 3(17) 52(72) 0 > ROUTE 3: Customers: 10 Vehicle: 2 Sequence: 0 72(65) 71(65) 65(42) 2(99) 69(40) 60(52) 68(96) 10(98) 49(30) 79(88) 0 > ROUTE 4: Customers: 13 Vehicle: 5 Sequence: 0 27(63) 66(57) 54(60) 24(58) 1(34) 36(55) 47(75) 15(32) 73(91) 14(60) 62(64) 38(72) 64(55) 0 > ROUTE 5: Customers: 15 Vehicle: 4 Sequence: 0 44(20) 18(96) 37(19) 61(90) 26(30) 77(28) 4(104) 17(42) 28(44) 25(35) 56(96) 78(42) 33(30) 34(56) 74(72) 0 > ROUTE 6: Customers: 12 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 50(108) 35(96) 12(87) 45(90) 42(80) 11(54) 31(42) 63(78) 5(87) 41(99) 59(45) 48(77) 0 >> PERIOD 9 > ROUTE 1: Customers: 22 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 35(156) 12(126) 45(150) 18(102) 37(114) 42(64) 11(42) 63(39) 31(98) 26(60) 77(91) 4(130) 17(77) 28(132) 25(120) 56(120) 78(84) 33(44) 34(105) 74(72) 48(98) 27(45) 0 > ROUTE 2: Customers: 28 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 44(75) 54(60) 24(72) 52(30) 16(91) 80(112) 3(34) 1(85) 68(40) 51(160) 60(65) 69(70) 36(25) 47(57) 15(24) 73(52) 65(91) 14(40) 62(80) 71(52) 38(24) 41(110) 5(105) 64(50) 72(26) 59(36) 83(70) 66(90) 0 > ROUTE 3: Customers: 28 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 39(90) 76(38) 6(40) 22(120) 49(70) 19(36) 20(30) 82(84) 58(84) 32(80) 57(36) 46(39) 9(90) 40(13) 13(27) 55(45) 43(55) 53(52) 21(98) 8(36) 7(65) 29(51) 70(64) 23(8) 67(28) 81(70) 79(56) 30(120) 0 >> PERIOD 10 > ROUTE 1: Customers: 11 Vehicle: 2 Sequence: 0 83(10) 71(26) 38(84) 62(16) 60(91) 1(102) 16(78) 6(76) 76(57) 39(90) 30(90) 0 > ROUTE 2: Customers: 13 Vehicle: 4 Sequence: 0 82(48) 58(98) 32(44) 57(54) 46(63) 9(90) 40(13) 13(54) 55(30) 43(22) 53(16) 21(14) 8(90) 0 > ROUTE 3: Customers: 8 Vehicle: 4 Sequence: 0 59(27) 11(82) 31(70) 63(78) 64(95) 72(78) 75(80) 44(85) 0 > ROUTE 4: Customers: 10 Vehicle: 4 Sequence: 0 66(72) 79(48) 81(84) 20(27) 70(80) 29(85) 23(64) 67(60) 27(27) 48(35) 0 > ROUTE 5: Customers: 14 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 54(20) 24(36) 68(80) 69(70) 14(30) 65(35) 2(54) 73(52) 15(88) 36(95) 3(17) 52(12) 10(84) 19(84) 0 > ROUTE 6: Customers: 6 Vehicle: 4 Sequence: 0 61(150) 37(76) 18(36) 74(48) 35(48) 50(90) 0 > ROUTE 7: Customers: 12 Vehicle: 1 >> PERIOD 11 > ROUTE 1: Customers: 8 Vehicle: 4 Sequence: 0 24(46) 1(85) 51(128) 14(20) 65(77) 62(16) 38(36) 71(39) 0 > ROUTE 2: Customers: 8 Vehicle: 2 Sequence: 0 67(32) 29(85) 8(72) 7(117) 70(64) 19(60) 49(50) 54(20) 0 > ROUTE 3: Customers: 12 Vehicle: 3 Sequence: 0 23(40) 58(28) 32(80) 57(45) 46(15) 9(45) 40(26) 13(63) 78(14) 4(78) 42(20) 44(15) 0 > ROUTE 4: Customers: 8 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 5(96) 26(66) 28(77) 25(90) 56(84) 17(98) 33(26) 45(20) 0 > ROUTE 5: Customers: 8 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 79(40) 53(84) 43(33) 55(90) 21(40) 82(72) 20(84) 81(84) 0 > ROUTE 6: Customers: 7 Vehicle: 3 Sequence: 0 52(48) 3(85) 80(72) 16(91) 22(80) 6(64) 76(38) 0 > ROUTE 7: Customers: 9 Vehicle: 3 Sequence: 0 59(27) 60(26) 73(65) 15(80) 47(18) 36(70) 69(100) 68(40) 66(27) 0 > ROUTE 8: Customers: 8 Vehicle: 3 Sequence: 0 75(124) 72(39) 64(50) 41(33) 11(52) 63(26) 31(70) 77(70) 0 > ROUTE 9: Customers: 6 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 48(49) 27(99) 34(91) 74(84) 12(69) 83(155) 0 > ROUTE 10: Customers: 9 Vehicle: 3 >> PERIOD 12 > ROUTE 1: Customers: 22 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 66(81) 76(57) 6(12) 22(60) 49(50) 19(96) 20(72) 82(60) 46(84) 9(45) 40(13) 13(81) 55(60) 43(66) 53(92) 21(94) 29(34) 70(48) 23(72) 67(88) 81(56) 30(90) 0 > ROUTE 2: Customers: 25 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 8(78) 58(70) 32(56) 57(90) 16(65) 80(80) 3(34) 1(51) 36(60) 47(36) 15(64) 73(65) 2(81) 65(56) 14(70) 69(50) 60(39) 68(64) 52(30) 10(126) 24(14) 54(30) 12(24) 35(70) 50(72) 0 > ROUTE 3: Customers: 26 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 44(15) 59(81) 72(65) 64(25) 71(13) 62(96) 38(96) 5(72) 41(22) 63(39) 31(56) 11(34) 42(32) 45(50) 18(36) 37(57) 61(180) 26(16) 77(35) 25(85) 28(99) 17(63) 4(65) 78(49) 33(80) 34(28) 0 > ROUTE 4: Customers: 2 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 27(81) 48(21) 0 >> PERIOD 13 > ROUTE 1: Customers: 21 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 79(80) 81(98) 23(64) 70(80) 82(60) 7(117) 8(36) 58(98) 32(52) 57(27) 46(60) 9(15) 40(91) 13(24) 55(90) 43(66) 53(80) 21(82) 29(51) 67(68) 30(75) 0 > ROUTE 2: Customers: 22 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 48(56) 27(54) 34(77) 74(36) 78(49) 4(52) 17(49) 28(99) 25(85) 56(96) 77(35) 26(56) 31(70) 63(13) 11(14) 42(24) 37(38) 18(90) 45(35) 12(78) 35(14) 50(72) 0 > ROUTE 3: Customers: 11 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 66(93) 39(72) 76(38) 6(84) 49(100) 19(72) 22(70) 52(72) 24(62) 54(80) 44(55) 0 > ROUTE 4: Customers: 24 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 20(69) 16(39) 80(56) 3(102) 1(51) 68(80) 51(48) 60(78) 69(40) 36(45) 47(60) 15(96) 73(65) 65(70) 14(10) 62(80) 71(65) 38(12) 41(99) 5(51) 64(15) 72(78) 59(63) 83(65) 0 >> PERIOD 14 > ROUTE 1: Customers: 78 Vehicle: 1 Sequence: 0 44(85) 66(21) 79(96) 76(19) 6(24) 22(50) 49(70) 20(27) 82(24) 58(84) 32(32) 57(81) 46(27) 9(45) 40(52) 13(93) 55(75) 43(11) 53(60) 21(16) 8(90) 29(34) 67(32) 23(24) 70(64) 19(24) 10(84) 24(86) 54(40) 83(80) 75(44) 59(63) 72(13) 64(85) 71(78) 1(17) 3(17) 80(32) 16(13) 52(60) 68(40) 60(26) 69(60) 36(85) 47(45) 15(80) 73(26) 2(27) 65(91) 14(60) 62(48) 38(48) 5(54) 41(99) 63(91) 31(70) 11(42) 42(68) 18(48) 37(38) 61(60) 26(10) 77(49) 56(84) 25(35) 28(55) 17(42) 4(65) 78(98) 33(86) 45(100) 12(12) 35(42) 74(84) 34(42) 27(72) 48(42) 30(60) 0